Opinions ahead!
The tenets presented here are opinions, which reasonable minds can disagree about. Instead, they aim to provide insight into the DM's thinking when making design choices.
If you disagree with anything here, the DM would love to discuss it with you.
These tenets explain the reasoning behind the homebrew rules, and why some officially printed 5.5e player feature have been revised. They are not hard rules, where every trace of content breaking them must be purged - one great aspect of the game is that some things are simply different.
Fantasy and lore are important
Characters that have connections to the world at large are easier to roleplay well. Thus, it is important that player options are reflected in the world. This does not mean that players should not be unique or special (they are always the protagonists of the story after all).
This mostly affects options from niche settings. A sentient ooze character using Spelljammer options may sound fun, but will struggle to engage well with a political intrigue quest. If a player truly wants to play this character, the DM may be willing to work with them to establish lore to ground them in the setting.
Examples:
Obvious best or worst choices are bad
If a feature offers multiple choices, but one choice overshadows the others to such a degree it is barely a choice, the underperforming options can likely be buffed. In some cases, the power discrepancy is so great that a nerf of the best option is warranted instead. This does not necessarily have to reduce the power of the option, but could instead aim at frequency or versatility.
Examples:
Weapon attacks with mental attributes
The two primary combat systems in the game are martial and magic. Both are powerful, with different strengths and weaknesses. For example, martial combatants are less reliant on resources, while magic users have more powers to control the battlefield. It is therefore very tempting to combine these, a character archetype known as the gish, after the gith'yanki champions of the Forgotten Realms. A well-built gish can be very powerful.
One hurdle any gish character must overcome is their ability score distribution. In officially printed content, subclasses that present a gish playstyle often completely elide this step by allowing characters to attack using their spellcasting ability. This removes an entire facet of these characters, where they can choose to focus more or less on either spells or swordplay.
Therefore, many of these features have been revised to require focusing on multiple ability scores. Most characters, and all gishes, should require at least some focus on one physical and one mental ability score. This creates more interesting characters with more choices.
Examples:
Players should not need the Monster Manual
Players should not have to reference the Monster Manual or other DM-facing content for their choices, especially at lower levels. Monsters run on different design philosophies, and player access to them should not be a concern when creating them.
For example, monster statblocks do not follow the same resting framework as player abilities. A monster is designed to bring all their tools to bear in the first rounds of combat, while players must last for the whole adventuring day and beyond.
Players are responsible to know their own features, just like the DM is responsible for the monsters. Temporarily borrowing a monster statblock is more likely to slow down gameplay when features have to be adjudicated, possibly in ways they were never intended to be used.
There are still some high-level spells, such as Dominate Monster or Shapechange that allow access to the Monster Manual, but at these levels characters are already incredibly strong.
Examples:
Clarity is paramount
Options should do what they say, and they should be easy to understand. This does not mean that complexity is bad.
Examples:
Homebrew systems
Some of the homebrew systems require updating official features to work well together.
All homebrew systems are designed to be modular, and a campaign may feature only some of them.
- Piety
- Hexcrawling
- Crafting magic items and Crafter